The Perils of AI-Generated Headshots: Why You Should Think Twice

In today’s fast-paced, tech-driven world, the promise of AI-generated headshots can seem like a quick and easy solution for professionals needing updated photos. The ads are tempting: upload a selfie, let AI do its magic, and within minutes you have a polished, professional-looking image—or so they claim. But as professional photographers with years of experience capturing authentic and compelling portraits, we couldn’t resist trying out these services ourselves to see what all the fuss was about. The results? Disappointing, to say the least.
Here’s what happened when we put an AI headshot company to the test—and why you should avoid them at all costs.
The Experiment: From Upload to "Professional"We selected one of the more popular AI headshot platforms for our trial. The process was straightforward: upload several selfies, choose a style, and wait for the AI to work its magic. Within minutes, we had a selection of headshots that promised to rival professional photography. At first glance, they looked decent. But the cracks quickly began to show.
The Problems with AI-Generated Headshots1. They Look UnnaturalAI might be getting better at mimicking human creativity, but the uncanny valley is alive and well. The headshots we received looked overly polished, almost cartoonish. Skin textures were smoothed to an unrealistic degree, facial features were subtly altered, and the lighting—while consistent—was flat and artificial. The end result felt more like a video game avatar than a genuine human being.
2. They Lack PersonalityA great headshot isn’t just about looking good; it’s about showcasing your personality and professionalism. AI-generated images fail miserably here. They’re generic and devoid of the subtle nuances that make you you. Employers and clients want to see the real person they’re working with, not an overly airbrushed approximation.
3. They’re Obvious to the Trained EyeAs photographers, we immediately spotted the telltale signs of AI generation: inconsistent detailing in the hair, odd blurring around the edges, and unrealistic shadows. But you don’t have to be an expert to notice something’s off. Prospective clients and employers will instinctively sense the lack of authenticity—and that can undermine your credibility.
4. They Can Harm Your Professional ImageYour headshot is often the first impression people have of you. An AI-generated image might save you time and money in the short term, but it can cost you in the long run. Employers and clients may view an AI headshot as lazy or untrustworthy, questioning your commitment to professionalism.
Why Authentic Photography MattersProfessional headshots aren’t just about lighting and composition; they’re about connection. A skilled photographer will take the time to understand your unique personality, industry, and goals, creating images that genuinely reflect who you are. They’ll guide you through poses, expressions, and styling to ensure you look your best—and, most importantly, look like yourself.
Our VerdictAfter testing an AI headshot service, it’s clear that these platforms are no substitute for the expertise and artistry of a professional photographer. While they may seem like a convenient solution, the results are anything but convincing. Instead of saving time and money, you risk damaging your professional image and missing out on opportunities.
The TakeawayInvesting in professional photography isn’t just about getting a great photo; it’s about presenting yourself in the best possible light. At Hummingbird Studios, we’re passionate about helping professionals make a lasting impression with headshots that are authentic, impactful, and tailored to their unique needs. Don’t settle for less. Your career deserves it.